Software Finder

Software Finder Payroll Comparison

Compare top payroll software.Find your best fit.

Compare Gusto, OnPay, QuickBooks Payroll and Patriot Payroll by the features, integrations and support your business needs, not just the price tag.

Get your payroll shortlist

Tell us about your team. Compare options matched to your payroll needs.

Software Finder is an independent marketplace that helps you compare payroll software. We do not perform credentialing or payer enrollment.

By submitting, you agree to Software Finder's Terms of Service and Privacy Policy and consent to be contacted by Software Finder and one or more matchedsoftware or service providers about your request. You can opt out at any time.

  • Compare features, not just fees
  • Match software to your team
  • Check integrations and tax coverage
  • Narrow down your next shortlist

Software Finder is a software marketplace. We may be compensated by vendors when buyers connect with them. The options below are not a ranked list; suitability and feature availability depend on your requirements and the selected plan.

THE SHORTLIST

Four payroll platforms. Different strengths.

Start with the workflow that matters most to your business, then compare the details side by side.

Gusto logo

Gusto

Payroll, benefits and HR together

An option for small and growing teams that want payroll, benefits and onboarding in a connected system.

Explore Gusto
OnPay logo

OnPay

Small-business payroll with core HR

An option for US small businesses that want payroll, employee records and PTO tools without choosing multiple feature tiers.

Explore OnPay
QuickBooks Payroll logo

QuickBooks Payroll

Teams already using QuickBooks

An option for businesses that want payroll expenses to flow into QuickBooks Online and employees to access pay details in Workforce.

Explore QuickBooks
Patriot Payroll logo

Patriot Payroll

Straightforward payroll with optional add-ons

An option for US small businesses that want to choose between filing taxes themselves and a full-service payroll plan.

Explore Patriot Payroll
Payroll software comparison at a glance
Compare byGustoOnPayQuickBooks PayrollPatriot Payroll
Business fitPayroll, benefits and HR togetherSmall-business payroll with core HRTeams already using QuickBooksStraightforward payroll with optional add-ons
Tax filingAutomatic federal, state and local filingsPayroll tax calculation and filingsAutomated filings; confirm local coverageAutomatic filing on Full Service; self-file on Basic
HR and time toolsBenefits, onboarding and time tools; plan-dependentEmployee records, onboarding and PTOWorkforce portal; time and HR support vary by planOptional HR and time-tracking add-ons
Accounting connectionsAccounting and time-tracking integrationsAccounting and time-tracking integrationsNative QuickBooks Online connectionPatriot Accounting and export options
Before you decideCheck which tier includes your time tracking and multi-state needs.Confirm support for your industry, time-tracking tool and reporting needs.Compare plan requirements for deposit speed, time tracking and HR support.Choose Basic or Full Service based on who will own tax filing.

Based on the product information used on our vendor pages. Features and plan inclusions may change. Confirm coverage, integrations and support with the provider before purchasing.

Compare what matters for your payroll.

Your workforce

Employees or contractors, hourly or salaried, one location or multiple states. Start with the people you need to pay.

Your compliance needs

Confirm who files taxes, which jurisdictions are covered and how corrections, garnishments and year-end forms are handled.

Your existing tools

Check the exact accounting, time-tracking and benefits connections you need, including whether they require an add-on.

Payroll comparison FAQs

A few answers before you make your shortlist.

Get your payroll shortlist

Tell us about your team. Compare options matched to your payroll needs.

Software Finder is an independent marketplace that helps you compare payroll software. We do not perform credentialing or payer enrollment.

By submitting, you agree to Software Finder's Terms of Service and Privacy Policy and consent to be contacted by Software Finder and one or more matchedsoftware or service providers about your request. You can opt out at any time.

YOUR NEXT STEP

Choose with a clearer comparison.

Tell us your headcount, current tools and payroll priorities. We’ll help you narrow the options and identify the differences worth discussing with each provider.

  • A shortlist aligned with your business needs
  • Feature and integration considerations
  • Questions to ask before you switch