Software Finder
SurePayroll logo

Logo shown is the property of SurePayroll, used for identification purposes only.

Get SurePayroll Pricing & Demo

Compare plans, book a live demo, and see how SurePayroll fits your business.

SurePayroll, part of Paychex, is an online payroll service built for small businesses and household employers. It runs payroll for employees and contractors, handles payroll tax filing on its full-service plan, and keeps reports and paystubs available online. Tell us your needs and we'll return current pricing.

Key takeaways

SurePayroll is an online payroll service for small businesses and household employers, backed by Paychex. It combines payroll runs for W-2 employees and 1099 contractors, direct deposit, automatic payroll tax filing on the full-service plan, and online reports and paystubs. Across public reviews, users frequently highlight how quick payroll is to run and the published, predictable pricing, while criticisms tend to centre on limited HR depth compared with larger platforms and on support wait times during busy periods.

Get Pricing

See the plan that fits your business

Share a few details and we'll send SurePayroll pricing matched to your payroll needs.

Independent guidance

Software Finder is an independent software marketplace, not SurePayroll, and not affiliated with or endorsed by them.

By submitting, you agree to Software Finder's Terms of Service and Privacy Policy and consent to be contacted by Software Finder and one or more matchedsoftware vendors (which may include SurePayroll) about your request. You can opt out at any time.

Overview

What is SurePayroll?

SurePayroll is a cloud payroll service aimed at small businesses, startups and household employers such as families employing a nanny. It processes payroll for salaried and hourly employees as well as contractors, offers direct deposit, and on its full-service plan calculates, files and deposits federal and state payroll taxes. Reports, paystubs and tax forms are available online, and payroll can be run from a browser or the mobile app. As part of Paychex, it sits alongside a wider family of payroll and HR services.

Best for

SurePayroll is best for small businesses that want straightforward, affordable payroll without the weight of a full HR suite, and for household employers who need nanny payroll handled properly. Its standout element is the combination of simple published pricing and full-service tax filing, which suits owners who want payroll done quickly with taxes taken care of.

Payroll

Run payroll from anywhere

SurePayroll runs payroll for W-2 employees and 1099 contractors on the schedule you choose, including salaried, hourly and multiple pay rates. Payroll can be started from the web or the mobile app, and runs can be scheduled to process automatically.

  • Unlimited payroll runs, including off-cycle runs
  • W-2 employees and 1099 contractors in one system
  • Free two-day direct deposit
SurePayroll mobile app showing the current payroll screen with pay period, approval date and check date
Payroll on web and mobile

Screenshots sourced from SurePayroll's publicly available materials and shown for identification and review purposes. Interface shown may differ from the current release.

Taxes

Payroll taxes calculated and filed

On the full-service plan, SurePayroll calculates, files and pays federal and state payroll taxes, with support for Social Security and Medicare calculations and access to forms including 940, 941, W-2 and 1099. Reports and paystubs stay available online around the clock.

  • Federal and state payroll tax filing and deposits
  • Tax forms including 940, 941, W-2 and 1099
  • Reports and paystubs available online 24/7
SurePayroll payroll summary showing gross pay, employee taxes, employer taxes and total payroll expenses
Tax calculation & filing

Screenshots sourced from SurePayroll's publicly available materials and shown for identification and review purposes. Interface shown may differ from the current release.

Plans

Simple, published pricing

SurePayroll publishes two small-business plans: a full-service option that includes tax filing, and a lower-cost option where you file taxes yourself. Both charge a flat monthly base fee plus a per-employee amount, and a household payroll option is available for nanny and home employers.

  • Full Service plan with taxes filed and deposited
  • No Tax Filing plan at a lower monthly cost
  • Household payroll option for nanny employers
SurePayroll plan cards showing the Full Service plan at $29 per month plus $7 per employee and the No Tax Filing plan at $20 per month
Published plans

Screenshots sourced from SurePayroll's publicly available materials and shown for identification and review purposes. Interface shown may differ from the current release.

Pricing

How much does SurePayroll cost?

SurePayroll publishes two small-business plans with a flat monthly base fee plus a per-employee charge, and a separate household payroll option. Promotional offers are frequently available for new customers.

Get Pricing

No Tax Filing

Core payroll features at a lower monthly cost, with you responsible for filing and depositing payroll taxes.

Full Service

Adds automatic payroll tax calculation, filing and deposits, plus support for W-2 employees and 1099 contractors.

Household payroll

A dedicated option for families paying nannies and other household employees.

Across public reviews, SurePayroll is often described as good value for very small teams, with buyers appreciating the transparent base-plus-per-employee structure. Some note that add-ons and year-end tax form fees can raise the total cost.

Pricing is subject to change.

Who it's for

Who is SurePayroll for?

Small businesses and startups
Household employers and nanny payroll
Retail and hospitality businesses
Professional services firms
Restaurants and food service
Accountants and bookkeeping firms

Use cases

Common ways teams use SurePayroll

Running payroll for employees and contractors

Pay W-2 staff and 1099 contractors on one system with unlimited runs and direct deposit.

Filing payroll taxes automatically

Have federal and state payroll taxes calculated, filed and deposited on the full-service plan.

Paying a nanny or household employee

Use the household payroll option to handle pay and taxes for domestic workers correctly.

Running payroll on the go

Start or schedule payroll from the mobile app when you are away from a desk.

What users say

Aggregated from public reviews, sentiment toward SurePayroll is generally favourable among very small businesses: users value the low entry price, the speed of running payroll and the straightforward interface. The most common criticisms concern customer support wait times at peak periods, fees for year-end forms and add-ons, and fewer built-in HR features than larger platforms. Reviewers are most often small-business owners, office managers and accountants.

Features

SurePayroll features

Capabilities listed on the official site, summarised in our own words. Exact availability varies by plan.

Full-service payroll

Run unlimited payroll for W-2 employees and 1099 contractors with multiple pay rates and schedules.

Automatic payroll tax filing

Calculate, file and deposit federal and state payroll taxes on the full-service plan.

Direct deposit

Pay employees by free two-day direct deposit, with reports and paystubs online.

Household payroll

A dedicated option for nanny and household employers, including tax handling.

Mobile payroll app

Start, review and schedule payroll runs from iOS and Android devices.

Pros & cons

SurePayroll pros and cons

Pros

  • Simple, published pricing
  • Payroll is quick to run
  • Automatic tax filing on full-service plan
  • Dedicated household payroll option
  • Backed by Paychex

Cons

  • Limited built-in HR features
  • Support wait times at peak periods
  • Extra fees for some forms and add-ons

FAQ

Common questions about SurePayroll

See SurePayroll in action

Request a demo

Share a few details and we'll help arrange a SurePayroll walkthrough for your workflow.

Software Finder is an independent software marketplace, not SurePayroll, and not affiliated with or endorsed by them.

By submitting, you agree to Software Finder's Terms of Service and Privacy Policy and consent to be contacted by Software Finder and one or more matchedsoftware vendors (which may include SurePayroll) about your request. You can opt out at any time.

Next step

Still comparing options? See SurePayroll in action.

Software Finder helps you gather the information that actually drives a software decision, a real walkthrough of SurePayroll and a clear view of how it compares to similar platforms.

  • See SurePayroll in a live walkthrough
  • Connect with the right team
  • Compare against similar platforms
  • Independent guidance